I Just Came for the Peeps, Part 2

This week my Peeps quest brings me back to Walmart for the three mystery flavors exclusive to the store this year. Upon close examination, all three flavors look exactly the same: traditional Peep shape with white sugar and white marshmallow centers. The looks certainly aren’t giving any hints as to what flavors are within the sugary chicks. Let’s dig in…

Peeps 1

Mystery Flavor #1: Packaging opened, first thing I noticed is nothing really. What I mean by that is nothing seems different. They smell just like normal peeps. Taste wise, mystery flavor one seems just a tad sweeter than original Peeps. Really nothing special.

My Guess: sugar cookie
My Rating: StarsStars

Peeps 2

Mystery Flavor #2: Definitely the oddest of the three flavors, it took me quite awhile to pinpoint what I was tasting. At first, I thought these were maple or maple and brown sugar, but then like The Ghost of Christmas Past… I REMEMBERED! That taste was so familiar, but I just couldn’t place it. Mystery Flavor number two tastes exactly like buttered popcorn flavored Jelly Belly jelly beans.

My Guess: buttered popcorn
My Rating: StarsStarsStarsStars

Peeps 3

Mystery Flavor #3: These smell like a cherry cordial. The second you open the package, a wave of cherry hits you in the face. It only took me one nibble to figure out the mystery flavor which was a punch of cherry and lime to my tongue.

My Guess: cherry limeade
My Rating: StarsStarsStarsStars

Next time: Fruit Punch and chocolate covered peeps

Anastasia Byrd
Scream Queen / Resident Foodie
Anastasia Byrd is a freelance writer, podcaster, avid horror fan, and thrash metal enthusiast. Ana also enjoys gaming with her husband and hanging out with her pet tarantula, Shelob. She lives and works somewhere in Mississippi (for now).
Anastasia Byrd on EmailAnastasia Byrd on Google

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *